Show Me How

Thursday, 19 November 2026


Why a good property manager will sometimes push back, and why it pays to listen


"I never liked him anyway."

Was what my friend's father said when she announced to her family that her 12-year marriage was over.

I SO get that a father's love is fierce and gloriously one-eyed but it blew my mind that he happily played house for over 12 years with a son-in-law he privately saw as a clerical error, and never said a word. Twelve Christmases. Countless barbecues. One wedding speech, presumably delivered through gritted teeth. Not O-N-E word.

Most of us are that dad more often than we'd admit. We question someone's judgement, smile politely, and save the truth for when it's safe and completely useless. At the family barbecue, fine. In property management, silence often comes with a price tag. Owners don't pay a property manager to nod. Nodding is what bobbleheads on dashboards do, and property managers are not bobbleheads.


The quick fix


I recently worked with a property manager whose owner had well and truly had enough. The house kept growing mould, the tenant wasn't keeping it clean, and her complaints about maintenance and healthy homes kept rolling in. Oh, and she was a lawyer.

His instruction to the property manager was simple: give her 90 days. Too much hassle. And, being a lawyer, too smart for his own good. His, the landlord's. Not the tenant's.

Ok, let's deal with the lawyer thing. Lawyer-tenants don't have better rights, they just know their rights better. And that's good for landlords. A tenant who knows her rights also knows her obligations, and exactly how much trouble she's in if she ignores them. Playing chess against someone who knows the rules is hard. Playing against someone who doesn't is impossible. The tenant to worry about is the one who thinks the rules are optional.

My advice: don't carry out this instruction. It had "retaliatory termination" stamped all over it. A 90-day notice served while a tenant's complaints are still live is the one move guaranteed to get her "law-dar" up. Under s54 of the Residential Tenancies Act, a tenant can ask the Tribunal to declare a notice retaliatory if it was given, even partly, because she complained or asserted her rights.

Here's how that plays out if you picture the Act as a choose-your-own-adventure game. You choose the 90-day notice. Bold. Decisive. Very efficient. The tenant applies to the Tribunal, which declares the notice retaliatory and of no effect. You're ordered to pay up to $6,500 in exemplary damages. And the tenant? Still living there, now with a renewed sense of purpose. Game over.

Quick fixes are irresistible precisely because they are quick and effortless. It's why crash diets sell, why "one weird trick" gets clicks, and why we would rather turn a broken printer off and on again than call tech support. The 90-day notice is sitting right there, like the last slice of pavlova, and it would be rude not to. It feels right in your gut. Let me tell you something, your gut isn't the one paying the bills.

So I coached the property manager to change the conversation with the owner from execution to facilitation. The owner didn't need someone to carry out his instruction. He needed someone who understood where he wanted to get to, and had the expertise to get him there. That's when the real options opened up.


The other paths


Fortunately, the Act offers several different ways to reach the same ending. Together, we explored three.

The first was a s56 notice requiring the tenant to remedy the cleanliness breach within 14 days. If she didn't, the owner could apply to the Tribunal to end the tenancy. This path front-loads the hard work: inspections, photos, file notes, and the owner's own maintenance obligations in good order. Once the Tribunal makes the order, though, the result is locked in.

The second was s55B. In the right circumstances, a landlord under a periodic tenancy can apply to the Tribunal to end it where the landlord would suffer greater hardship than the tenant and it would be unreasonable to make them carry on. A bit of a stretch goal this one but given the particulars of the matter, I did not rule it out.

The third was a negotiated exit. The manager knew exactly how this tenant was wired and what made her tick. With the right incentives and a few sensible concessions, ending the tenancy by agreement could leave everyone feeling they'd won something.

All three are slower to start. All three are far quicker to an ending that sticks. The shortest first step is often the longest road.

The owner chose. That was always his call.


Where, not how


Asking a professional for a solution and telling them how to do their job are two very different conversations. Ask for a solution, and you get everything you're paying for: their experience, their options and their read on the risks. Tell them how to do it, and the best you can hope for is your own idea, carried out by someone who probably saw the problem coming.

If there is one thing I want owners to take away from this article, it is this:

Tell your manager where you want to get to, not how to get you there.

And when your manager pushes back, resist the very human urge to dig in. Try three words instead:

"Show me how."

Then step back and let them figure it out.


The pushback worth paying for


There are three moments when a good property manager should push back: when an instruction is unlawful, when it carries serious risk, or when it works against your own interests. And good pushback always comes with another way to get where you're going.

Think of your GP. The doctor who hands out antibiotics whenever you ask is the one to worry about. Pushing back on a paying client costs a manager something, which is exactly why you can believe it. A manager who never pushes back is just you, charging you.

So when your property manager says, "Before you go that way, can I show you the others?", take the offer.

It beats hearing "I always knew you were wrong" in 12 years' time.



Sarina Gibbons

Behind the insights


Sarina Gibbon leads Tenancy Advisory, which helps New Zealand property managers and owners make confident, lawful tenancy decisions.

This article is general information, not legal advice. 






Want to know more about Property Brokers' superior property management service? Check out our FREE guide here!  

Browse


Topic
Year


Show Me How

Read more

Sarina Gibbon from Tenancy Advisory explores why the best property managers aren't simply there to follow instructions, but to challenge thinking, protect your investment and find better ways forward. With a healthy dose of humour and some real-world insight, she explains why a little professional pushback could save you considerable time, money and stress.
Read More
The rental market has changed. Has your investment strategy?

Read more

For the past few years, property investors have had plenty to think about. Interest rates, changing legislation, rising costs and rapidly moving rents have dominated the conversation.
Read More

Find us

Find a Salesperson

From the top of the North through to the deep South, our salespeople are renowned for providing exceptional service because our clients deserve nothing less.

Find a Property Manager

Managing thousands of rental properties throughout provincial New Zealand, our award-winning team saves you time and money, so you can make the most of yours.

Find a branch

With a team of over 900 strong in more than 90 locations throughout provincial New Zealand, a friendly Property Brokers branch is likely to never be too far from where you are.