Navigating the boundary between structural and cyclical dynamics

Friday, 8 December 2023


In the ever-evolving landscape of New Zealand's agricultural sector, the dairy industry is witnessing a paradigm shift.


Decades of experience have seasoned these growers, imbuing them with an understanding of the inherent volatility of their profession. With a tenacity that sets them apart, they navigate challenges, proving that resilience is not just a word but a guiding force.

Conrad Wilkshire, Property Brokers' Rural General Manager, with over 30 years of experience in rural property, sheds light on the transformative forces at play.

Unlike the production-led growth phases of the 90s and 2000s, the dairy sector today faces a unique narrative. Despite a remarkable increase in export receipts—currently contributing a staggering $25 billion to New Zealand's economy—the sector has seen minimal growth in milk production since 2014. This paradoxical scenario has profound implications for the property market, sparking the need for innovative solutions.



According to Wilkshire, the challenge lies in the changing dynamics of the industry. While there's a considerable reduction in the number of dairy farmers annually, the underlying asset value has not seen a significant lift. This marks a departure from the traditional approach where capital uplifts were driven by production increases.



Recognizing this shift, Property Brokers is pioneering a new strategy to bring fresh blood into the dairy farming landscape. The focus is on smaller-scale transactions, providing an opportunity for young, ambitious farmers to enter the market without the burden of exorbitant upfront costs.

Wilkshire emphasizes that the key to this strategy is the introduction of lease-to-buy options. In these arrangements, aspiring dairy farmers can purchase part of the property while leasing the remaining portion under mutually agreed terms. Successful deployments of this model have been witnessed in transactions ranging from five to $6 million, offering a practical solution to the daunting challenge of getting a foothold on the rural property ladder.

The rationale behind this approach is twofold. On one side, young and progressive farmers, armed with significant capital and a track record of success, get the opportunity to take ownership of a portion of a dairy farm. On the other side, retiring vendors with smaller-scale operations are provided an exit option that ensures the continuity of their legacy.

The unique aspect of this model is its flexibility in terms of settlement periods, typically ranging from two to five years. During this time, the purchaser operates as an owner-operator, proving their capability to the vendor and the bank. This strategy mitigates risks for both parties, fostering a symbiotic relationship with shared goals.



Unlike the long-term leases seen in horticulture, the dairy model revolves around a shorter settlement period. This is attributed to the end goal of outright ownership, a stark contrast to the extended investment horizon seen in other agricultural sectors.



Addressing concerns about potential challenges, Wilkshire remains optimistic. Even in the face of environmental regulations, greenhouse gas taxes, and market fluctuations, he argues that supply and demand economics will prevail. The shrinking number of dairy farmers, combined with a commitment to sustainability and compliance, positions the dairy sector for resilience and profitability.

In essence, this new approach to dairy farming property ownership not only provides a strategic solution to market challenges but also ensures the continuity of the dairy industry's contribution to New Zealand's economic landscape. As young, dynamic farmers embrace the opportunity to own a slice of the dairy pie, and retiring vendors find willing successors, the stage is set for a transformative chapter in New Zealand's dairy story.




Have a listen to our latest podcast episode on Property Perspectives where we delve into the latest rural market insights


Browse


Topic
Year


The Hidden Risk in Building Your Property Portfolio With One Bank

Read more

Not all banks assess lending the same way. One lender may take a conservative view on rental income. Another may shade living expenses differently. Some may favour new builds or townhouses, while others may have stricter policies around apartments or investor lending.
Read More
From Fixer-Upper to Forever Home: The 2026 Playbook for First-Time Buyers

Read more

We’re seeing more Kiwis get ahead by stepping away from the traditional buying model and choosing homes that need a little TLC. In 2026, Sweat Equity, swapping your weekend DIY time for real gains in your bank balance, is one of the smartest ways to break into the market.
Read More
Stronger returns, lower debt, rising confidence across rural New Zealand

Read more

Discover the Rural New Zealand Market Outlook 2026, including dairy payouts, farm debt trends, export growth, and why confidence is rising across the agricultural sector.
Read More

Find us

Find a Salesperson

From the top of the North through to the deep South, our salespeople are renowned for providing exceptional service because our clients deserve nothing less.

Find a Property Manager

Managing thousands of rental properties throughout provincial New Zealand, our award-winning team saves you time and money, so you can make the most of yours.

Find a branch

With a team of over 850 strong in more than 88 locations throughout provincial New Zealand, a friendly Property Brokers branch is likely to never be too far from where you are.